Wednesday, March 21, 2012

John Carlin- journalist, author

"John Carlin (born 12 May 1956)[1] is a journalist and author, dealing with both sports and politics. His book Playing the Enemy: Nelson Mandela and the Game that Made a Nation about former South African president Nelson Mandela is the basis for the 2009 film Invictus." - Wikipedia.com


"Journalism is the pass to extraordinary events, people, and parts of the world
In this talk, John Carlin revealed to us the nature of journalism. Journalism is a medium in our media, which plays a strong role in our perception of the world. It is our source of information, which creates and shapes our opinions and perception. 

In this talk, Carlin told us anecdotes and messages he had picked up from his experiences. His far most memorable and cherished were his encounters with Nelson Mandela, whom he described to have a charisma and confidence of a hero. Carlin's first encounter with this great man was at his release after 27 years of imprisonment; when he stepped out, surrounded by media including Carlin, ready to change the country. Working for the Independent at the time, Carlin had felt, and known, that this was a great moment in history, and to be witnessing it was one of the privileges of a journalist. 


Mandela's challenge after becoming president was going to be to negotiate on opposition arms. In an interview, Carlin asked him what his formula was going to be. Mandela answered he was going to reconcile black aspirations and white fears: "Respect" for one another is one of the most important social qualities, and in order to reach an understanding and gain respect, he had to know his enemy better. This Mandela had done by learning Afrikaans during his imprisonment, and getting to know the culture and individual personalities of the brutish white prison guards. 


This helped Mandela, as he won over the respect of the prison guards, later the Chief of "In"justice, the head of Secret Intelligence, and even the leader of a white opposition group that emerged, who was an ex-general, ambitious to oppose. By respecting this leader greatly, Mandela was able to convince the 'terrorist' to abandon the group and participate in elections. "I was told I was a coward to talk to the opposition leader. They were wrong: I managed to obtain peace."(Mandela). The respect for the white culture also included the aim that even in the newly reformed country, there had to be a sense of belonging for everyone. When the new government was deciding upon an national anthem, Mandela was wise and made the decision to have both the black and white anthems, so there would not be a feeling of separation and black dominance over the country. Mandela had great political leadership: the power to bend people to your will. He invested a lot of immense respect and trust in people for this, but instead, when he felt betrayed, he was implacable. 


So what was Carlin's view on the nature of journalism? What he had recounted for us showed this: it was a witness account of Carlin's experiences, where he tried to be accurate as possible about the events and the atmosphere, yet there was also messages within this story. "Objectivity in journalism is impossible", and all people have a bias. Carlin stated that "objectivity is a myth", but at least he tried to be as truthful as possible in what he wrote. 
Thus Carlin commented that the reliability of articles were that they were "only approximations of the truth". Some journalists will have more elements of inventions, with ulterior motives. Carlin himself said he was a mercenary, writing articles on various subjects because he was asked to. Nonetheless journalism is normally the best attempts at the truth, by the journalist. 

1 comment:

  1. 'only approximations of the truth' this is a gem of a quote and one can't help but feel this is honest and also disturbing when considering knowledge, truth and certainty.
    Very detailed summary and excellent note taking.

    ReplyDelete